Search Weight Loss Topics: |
Separation of church and school? Justices will weigh Maine’s ban on funds for religious education – SCOTUSblog


Case Preview ByAmy Howe on Dec 7, 2021 at 4:01 pm
On Wednesday the Supreme Court will hear oral argument in a challenge to a Maine program that pays for some students to attend private schools. Two families that want to send their children to Christian schools in the state argue that the states exclusion of schools that provide religious instruction from the program violates the Constitution. Although the justices ruling will directly affect fewer than 5,000 students in Maine, the courts eventual decision could have a significant impact on public funding for religious education well beyond the states border.
The dispute, Carson v. Makin, centers on the system that Maine uses to ensure that all school-aged children in the state have an opportunity to receive a free public education. With fewer than 180,000 students in kindergarten through 12th grade, distributed over 260 school districts, not all school districts operate their own secondary schools. Instead, some districts make arrangements with specific private schools or other public schools to take their students. And other school districts allow their students to choose their own public or private school and pay their tuition. However, the Maine program only allows tuition payments to go to private schools that are nonsectarian that is, schools that do not provide religious instruction.
The plaintiffs in the case are two sets of parents who live in districts that do not operate their own secondary schools. As a result, their children were eligible to receive tuition assistance to attend private schools approved by the state. David and Amy Carson sent their daughter to Bangor Christian, in the city of Bangor, because the schools Christian worldview aligns with their sincerely held religious beliefs. Troy and Angela Nelson would like to send their son to Temple Academy, a Christian school in Waterville, but cant afford it without tuition-assistance payments.
After the Supreme Courts 2017 ruling in Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia v. Comer, holding that the Constitutions free exercise clause barred the government from denying the church a benefit that is otherwise available to the public just because of the churchs religious status, the Carsons and the Nelsons went to federal court. They argued that the exclusion of religious schools from Maines tuition-assistance program likewise violates the free exercise clause.
While the parents case was pending, the Supreme Court issued its decision in another school-funding case, Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue. By a vote of 5-4, the justices ruled in June 2020 that although states are not required to subsidize private education, they cannot exclude families or schools from participating in programs to provide public funding for private schools because of a schools religious status. The court left open the question whether the state could exclude families or schools from the program because the money would be used for religious purposes at school.
In a decision in October 2020, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 1st Circuit (with a panel that included retired Justice David Souter) rejected the parents challenge to the Maine program. It held that unlike the religious exclusions in Trinity Lutheran and Espinoza, the Maine law does not bar schools from receiving funding simply based on their religious identity. Instead, the court of appeals explained, the exclusion examines what the school teaches through its curriculum and related activities, and the law prohibits schools from receiving funding because of the religious use to which they would put the funds. The law, the court of appeals concluded, merely reflects Maines refusal to subsidize religious exercise.
The parents went to the Supreme Court, which agreed last summer to weigh in.
In their brief on the merits, the parents contend that Maines exclusion of sectarian options from its tuition-assistance program violates the Constitution because it is not neutral toward religion nor generally applicable, the test used in free exercise clause cases. It isnt neutral, the parents say, because the program only allows private schools to participate if they are nonsectarian. And it isnt generally applicable, they argue, because it requires state officials to make judgment calls based on the degree of a religious schools religiosity. Therefore, they conclude, it is subject to the most stringent constitutional test, known as strict scrutiny, which it fails.
More broadly, the parents tell the justices, there is no basis for the 1st Circuits effort to distinguish between religious status and religious use. Indeed, they suggest, the framers of the Constitution opted to protect religious exercise, rather than mere belief or conscience, to ensure that Americans would be free to live out their faith. And for these parents and others who would use the tuition-assistance program, they explain, ensuring that their children receive a religious education is a religious obligation; barring them from participating in the tuition-assistance program because the funds would be used for religious purposes discriminates not only against that religious use, but also against the religious status that impels it.
The parents stress that the Supreme Court has never endorsed a distinction between religious status and use as grounds for eluding strict scrutiny of laws that discriminate based on religion. If the justices suggested such a distinction in Locke v. Davey, a 2004 ruling in which the court upheld the constitutionality of a publicly funded scholarship program that excluded students from pursuing a degree in devotional theology, the parents write, it was wrongly decided and should be overruled.
However, the parents continue, the justices can strike down the exclusion of sectarian schools from Maines tuition-assistance program without overruling Locke. Among other things, they note, the exclusion is significantly broader than the one at issue in Locke, which focused on training ministers to lead congregations. Here, they point out, Maines program bars any assistance to schools that teach religion. And neither of Maines justifications for the exclusion is the kind of historic and substantial interest envisioned in Locke, they say. The exclusion stems from an opinion by the states attorney general indicating that the state should carve out sectarian options to avoid violating the Constitutions establishment clause, they observe. Maines argument that it only wants to pay tuition at private schools that provide educations similar to what students would receive in public school also came after it had already created the exclusion, the parents contend, and in any event it is neither compelling not historic and substantial: Indeed, in this countrys early years, governments often provided religious schools with public funding to pay, for example, to educate the poor, Native Americans, and residents of the District of Columbia.
For its part, Maine portrays its tuition-assistance program (and the decision to exclude sectarian schools from the program) as a unique one, intended to provide students who live in school districts without their own secondary schools with the equivalent of the education that they would have received in a public school. Emphasizing the important role of public education in fostering democracy and good citizenship, the state explains that it has concluded that a public education should be a nonsectarian one that exposes children to diverse viewpoints, promotes tolerance and acceptance, teaches academic subjects in a religiously neutral manner, and does not promote a particular faith or belief system. That determination to make a public education nonsectarian, the state continues, is at the heart of its decision to limit the tuition-assistance program to nonsectarian schools, because it wants to ensure that every child has access to a free public education i.e., a religiously-neutral education where subject matter is not taught through the lens of any particular faith.
Because the tuition-assistance program is simply intended to replicate a public education, Maine continues, it is different from other school-choice programs that provide public funds to families who for academic, religious, athletic, or other reasons want to opt out of the public education system, and send their children to private schools. Instead, the state stresses, the tuition-assistance program is only available to the limited subset of families who live in school districts that dont operate their own secondary schools and dont make arrangements for their students to attend specific schools.
Therefore, the state tells the justices, the Carsons and the Nelsons are not being denied a generally available public benefit because they cannot attend Christian schools at state expense. The benefit that Maine is offering, the state explains, is a free public education. If Maine only provided a public education through its public schools, the state notes, the Carsons and Nelsons children would not have a constitutional right to attend sectarian schools at public expense. The result should be no different, the state writes, simply because Maine sometimes makes use of privately-owned schools to provide a public education.
Maine assures the justices that the exclusion of sectarian schools from its tuition-assistance program is not motivated by hostility to religion, but instead by the belief that a public education is both defined by inclusion and tolerance, and reflective of the diversity of our students and our community. In this case, it observes, Bangor Christian and Temple Academy will only hire born-again Christians as teachers, and the schools acknowledge that they will not hire LGBTQ teachers or admit LGBTQ students. Although the schools have a right to maintain these policies, the state concedes, Maine is not required to fund their educational program as the substantive equivalent of a public education.
Appearing as a friend of the court supporting Maine, the federal government focuses on an argument that Maine also makes: The Nelsons and the Carsons do not have a legal right, known as standing, to bring this lawsuit in the first place. The parents could only send their children to Temple Academy and Bangor Christian if those schools decide to accept public funds, and both sides in the case agree that it is uncertain whether the schools would do so if the law were struck down. Moreover, the government adds, the Nelsons daughter has graduated, and their son now attends another school, so their only injury is that they cant send their son to Temple Academy using public funds. And, the government continues, the Carsons claims are moot that is, no longer a live controversy because their daughter has recently graduated from high school.
Friend-of-the-court briefs filed on both sides of the issue warn the justices that sweeping consequences are likely to flow from the courts ruling. Supporting the parents, the Liberty Justice Center tells the justices that the ability to use public funding to attend private schools is a lifeboat for a wide range of children not only children from low-income and urban families but also students with special physical or intellectual needs, victims of bullying, religious minorities, tribal students, and children of military families. Because roughly two-thirds of all private schools in the United States are religious, the group explains, excluding faith-based schools from public-funding programs would severely curtail[] the educational options available to families.
The National Association of School Boards, which filed a brief supporting Maine, counters that a ruling for the families could create significant damage to public education by eliminating the distinction between religious status and religious use and therefore opening the gate for widespread public funding of private schools. Faced with a scenario in which they are required to fund religious education, the association predicts, states would likely expand their voucher and school-choice programs dramatically or shut them completely.
This article was originally published at Howe on the Court.
See the original post:
Separation of church and school? Justices will weigh Maine's ban on funds for religious education - SCOTUSblog
- Therapists, trainers offer wealth of health and fitness options in U.S. Army Garrison Wiesbaden - United States Army - April 29th, 2022
- Genetics: Why It's Hard to Increase Running Speed - Healthline - April 29th, 2022
- 'A great environment for them': How a Raynham gym caters to young adults with disabilities - Taunton Daily Gazette - April 29th, 2022
- 10 spring things at Brandeis and beyond | BrandeisNOW - Brandeis University - April 29th, 2022
- Health Professions Programs to Expand, Diversify Workforce - The University of Arizona Health Sciences | - April 29th, 2022
- Eagles offseason workout program begins today - Bleeding Green Nation - April 29th, 2022
- Horned Frogs in the News, April 8-25 - TCU - April 29th, 2022
- Where to Find Free Outdoor Workout Classes in Cincinnati this Spring - Cincinnati CityBeat - April 29th, 2022
- A combination of three simple treatments may reduce invasive cancer risk by 61% among adults aged 70+ - EurekAlert - April 29th, 2022
- State higher ed board approves creation of new academic programs, cuts one - Grand Forks Herald - April 29th, 2022
- A portion of Magnuson Park will be closed on Friday, April 29, to allow for a joint Army/Navy/Air Force/NOAA training exercise - Parkways - Parkways... - April 29th, 2022
- Dangers of distracted driving, how to correct a skid part of upcoming BRAKES course for teens - MLive.com - April 29th, 2022
- Wearable fitness tracker use in federally qualified health center patients: strategies to improve the health of all of us using digital health devices... - April 29th, 2022
- Analysis: Every so often, Texas government needs a reboot - The Texas Tribune - April 29th, 2022
- TORM : Capital increase in TORM due to exercise of Restricted Share Units as part of TORM's incentive program - Form 6-K - Marketscreener.com - April 29th, 2022
- What Is the 75 Hard Challenge? And Should You Try the Program? - Prevention Magazine - March 22nd, 2022
- SilverSneakers Opens Nominations for 2022 Instructor of the Year - PR Newswire - March 22nd, 2022
- Physical Exercise and Mental Health the Mind-Body Connection Mountaineer Echo - The Mountaineer Echo - March 22nd, 2022
- At Westerly Library & Wilcox Park: Kickstart your fitness with the Run Club - The Westerly Sun - March 22nd, 2022
- Beachbody Breaks New Ground in GUT HEALTH Mega-Trend With New Program from Autumn Calabrese, Super Trainer, Nutrition Expert and Best-Selling Author -... - March 22nd, 2022
- Jean-Luc Mlenchon Has a Radical Program. Implementing It Would Be Far Tougher. - Jacobin magazine - March 22nd, 2022
- St. Joseph County Commission on Aging Advisory Board approves 2020 annual report - Sturgis Journal - March 22nd, 2022
- GYAC Selected by NASA for In-flight Education Downlink - WQCS - March 22nd, 2022
- Skip the Gym and Stream These Workouts on Your TV - CNET - March 22nd, 2022
- Hunter's Laptop and the Common Good - AMAC - March 22nd, 2022
- Fitness and Nutrition Awards | Best Fitness and Food Products - Runner's World - January 3rd, 2022
- New Year's Resolutions: How to Make a Better Fitness Resolution - GQ - January 3rd, 2022
- Start 2022 off right with great workout deals from Echelon Fitness - BGR - January 3rd, 2022
- County Commission considering beer and wine tours, other zoning changes - The Missourian - January 3rd, 2022
- 'Tony Dancer' rings in 2022 with Bath's historic Paul Revere bell - pressherald.com - January 3rd, 2022
- Get ahead of winter inactivity with an inspired home workout space - Jersey's Best - January 3rd, 2022
- WW failed to cash in on the diet craze in 2021 - New York Post - January 3rd, 2022
- The Benefits of Using Technology for Senior Care What You Should Know - The Future of Things - January 3rd, 2022
- How to Turn Back the Clock on Aging, Say Experts Eat This Not That - Eat This, Not That - January 3rd, 2022
- Here's how Northeast Louisiana kids can get active, healthy in 2022 - The News Star - January 3rd, 2022
- Penacook Community Center to merge with Boys and Girls Club - Concord Monitor - January 3rd, 2022
- Getting Back On Top: How to Rebuild the Navy - USNI News - January 3rd, 2022
- 2021: A Year in Review > US Cyber Command > News - United States Cyber Command - January 3rd, 2022
- How 5 Unique Women Navigated Their Body Goals With WW's New Program - Brit + Co - January 3rd, 2022
- Volusia libraries returning to live action | News | hometownnewsvolusia.com - Hometown News - January 3rd, 2022
- Pitt to begin spring term remotely, implement shelter-in-place starting Jan. 8 due to COVID-19 concerns - WTAE Pittsburgh - January 3rd, 2022
- Here are all the tenants inside the Maritime and Defense Technology Hub - St Pete Catalyst - January 3rd, 2022
- 12 of the Best Treadmills for the Ultimate At-Home Workout - PureWow - December 23rd, 2021
- PATHWAYS TO HEALING: Why should I participate in chair yoga? - Lake Oconee Breeze - December 23rd, 2021
- Spread cheer by gifting you and your friend a workout app that's 70% off - mySanAntonio.com - December 23rd, 2021
- Ring In The New Year With An 'Anti' Resolution List - Your Valley - December 23rd, 2021
- Upcoming Granby Council on Aging events and programs - Reminder Publications - December 23rd, 2021
- 75 HARD Challenge: What You Need to Know Before Starting - Greatist - December 23rd, 2021
- Anti-Aging Secrets That Experts Use Themselves Eat This Not That - Eat This, Not That - December 23rd, 2021
- Athletico Physical Therapy Opens in Rockwall North - PRNewswire - December 23rd, 2021
- These Fitness Coaching Apps Can Help You Stay Fit With Your Phone - menshealth.com - December 23rd, 2021
- 7 Hacks That Improve Your Memory, According to Science Eat This Not That - Eat This, Not That - December 23rd, 2021
- 10 employee benefits that enhance workplace wellness programs - AZ Big Media - December 23rd, 2021
- Exercise Definition & Meaning - Merriam-Webster - December 9th, 2021
- Blood pressure has spiked during the pandemic, but these tips can help you lower yours - PhillyVoice.com - December 9th, 2021
- Cardiovascular disease: What level of physical activity is helpful? - Medical News Today - December 9th, 2021
- Compete: Global Virtual Fitness Market to Hit $59,650.3 Million by 2027, Growing at a CAGR of 33.5% from 2020 to 2027 - Informative [251 pages] Report... - December 9th, 2021
- Athletico Physical Therapy Opens in Arlington West - PRNewswire - December 9th, 2021
- Information Session Set for Graduate Programs at U of A Office of Entrepreneurship and Innovation - University of Arkansas Newswire - December 9th, 2021
- Virtual reality therapy? New arcade in South Bend hopes to offer more than games - South Bend Tribune - December 9th, 2021
- We Are Santa Monica Fund to Accept Donations for Broader Uses to Support Local Recovery, Equity and Vulnerable Residents - santamonica.gov - December 9th, 2021
- Emergency Management Institute (EMI) - EMI Programs and ... - October 27th, 2021
- Exercise Science BS | RIT - October 27th, 2021
- Rec center renovation in Texarkana nearly completed - Arkansas Online - October 27th, 2021
- How Letting My Weaknesses Show Helped in Rehab - Everyday Health - October 27th, 2021
- Area police and fire agencies to conduct training exercise at Blackwell Oct. 30 - Chicago Daily Herald - October 27th, 2021
- How exercise may improve your sight - The Science Show - ABC Radio National - ABC News - October 27th, 2021
- Athletico Physical Therapy Opens in Byron - PRNewswire - October 27th, 2021
- Dept. of Military Affairs: Wisconsin Emergency Management works with partners to enhance planning and preparedness coordination - Wisbusiness.com - October 27th, 2021
- Kids with obesity need acceptance from family and friends, not just better diet tips, to succeed at managing their weight - Yahoo News - October 27th, 2021
- Is back pain preventing you from doing the activities you love? - CDB News - October 27th, 2021
- Madelyn Jones Named Director of Employer Relations for College of Education and Health Professions - University of Arkansas Newswire - October 27th, 2021
- Adherence to Home Exercise Programs - Physiopedia - October 5th, 2021
- Committee on Accreditation for the Exercise Sciences ... - October 5th, 2021
- How to Maintain Your New Drive to Exercise as You Return to Work - Healthline - October 5th, 2021
- Tampa General Hospital and Home Base Partner to Offer a Free Health and Fitness Program to Tampa Bay Area Veterans - KKCO-TV - October 5th, 2021
- Tampa General, Home Base team up to help veterans with PTSD - The Capitolist - October 5th, 2021
- Use the Dumbbell Deadlift to Perfect Your Pull - BarBend - October 5th, 2021
- How to Get Employees to (Actually) Participate in Well-Being Programs - Harvard Business Review - October 5th, 2021
- A Day in the Life: Interning in Tel Aviv - jewishboston.com - October 5th, 2021